Wow - Obese Woman\'s Husband Suing the Airlines...

ShoeDiva said:
unionmom said:
According to the article, 3 airlines tried. (and at least two airports)

I have no clue to how the husband thinks he can sue when so much was tried. :dunno

...Although a local fire department were brought in to help move Mrs Soltesz into three seats assigned to her, they could not lift her out of the wheelchair.

After half an hour of trying to move her, the captain asked them to leave the plane.

'We had 140 passengers on board, and they had connections and needed to travel,' said Lufthansa spokesman Nils Haupt.

'The question was never the seat belt. The question was the mobility of the passenger.'...
 
A few more things, in random order:

- it seems they were returning as originally planned

- she did gain a notable amount of weight making previous accommodations no longer work

- hubby's mindset ... “They managed to get her over there and were obligated to get her home.”

- if it were my call ... DISMISSED, next case please.
 
unionmom said:
A few more things, in random order:

- it seems they were returning as originally planned

- she did gain a notable amount of weight making previous accommodations no longer work

- hubby's mindset ... “They managed to get her over there and were obligated to get her home.”

- if it were my call ... DISMISSED, next case please.

:thumbsup
 
ShoeDiva said:
LisaC said:
deewee said:
It all boils down to personal responsibility. They made a dumb decision to fly overseas when they knew they could be facing some issues with the trip (health problems, not being able to get on a plane without assistance, can't buckle in a plane without assistance) and now they want someone else to pay for their dumb decision.

But, here is what doesn't make sense. The airline got them there, asked for their return flight information so they could insure that they could transport her, and then couldn't they get them back. What did they do over here that they couldn't do over there? Something had to have happened to keep them from doing that, right? Airlines are generally consistent in using the same size planes to fly in/out of a particular city so I'm not sure why they couldn't get her back on the same size plane.

Again, not disagreeing with you about personal responsibility, but they could have easily been led to believe that if they could get her over there, surely the airline could get her back, right? Like I said, I'm scratching my head on this one...

She gained about another 100lbs while over there and they did try numerous times to get her on and could not.
Oh my gosh! What did she eat? A child?
 
deewee said:
ShoeDiva said:
LisaC said:
deewee said:
It all boils down to personal responsibility. They made a dumb decision to fly overseas when they knew they could be facing some issues with the trip (health problems, not being able to get on a plane without assistance, can't buckle in a plane without assistance) and now they want someone else to pay for their dumb decision.

But, here is what doesn't make sense. The airline got them there, asked for their return flight information so they could insure that they could transport her, and then couldn't they get them back. What did they do over here that they couldn't do over there? Something had to have happened to keep them from doing that, right? Airlines are generally consistent in using the same size planes to fly in/out of a particular city so I'm not sure why they couldn't get her back on the same size plane.

Again, not disagreeing with you about personal responsibility, but they could have easily been led to believe that if they could get her over there, surely the airline could get her back, right? Like I said, I'm scratching my head on this one...

She gained about another 100lbs while over there and they did try numerous times to get her on and could not.
Oh my gosh! What did she eat? A child?
:spitchick Hilarious! (I am guessing it has something to do with her illness. How else could you gain that much?)
 
deewee said:
ShoeDiva said:
LisaC said:
deewee said:
It all boils down to personal responsibility. They made a dumb decision to fly overseas when they knew they could be facing some issues with the trip (health problems, not being able to get on a plane without assistance, can't buckle in a plane without assistance) and now they want someone else to pay for their dumb decision.

But, here is what doesn't make sense. The airline got them there, asked for their return flight information so they could insure that they could transport her, and then couldn't they get them back. What did they do over here that they couldn't do over there? Something had to have happened to keep them from doing that, right? Airlines are generally consistent in using the same size planes to fly in/out of a particular city so I'm not sure why they couldn't get her back on the same size plane.

Again, not disagreeing with you about personal responsibility, but they could have easily been led to believe that if they could get her over there, surely the airline could get her back, right? Like I said, I'm scratching my head on this one...

She gained about another 100lbs while over there and they did try numerous times to get her on and could not.
Oh my gosh! What did she eat? A child?
Kidney problems ...water weight.

Obesity is one of the leading causes of kidney disease, but having the disease itself can be a factor in other kinds of weight problems.

One of the side effects of kidney disease is fluid retention, also called edema. A normal kidney naturally flushes out water, salt and other fluids from our bodies on a regular basis, but a malfunctioning kidney is much more slow at this process. The result is weight gain that results from retained water as the fluids are not properly excreted into the urine. Normally this weight gain and puffiness can be seen in certain areas of the body, such as the ankles, feet, legs, hands, belly and face. As stages of kidney disease advance, this water retention can lead to additional problems.

http://www.3fatchicks.com/3-effects-of-kidney-disease-on-weight/
 
And it still isn't the airlines' faults ... that is a major change in the needed accommodations to assist her in her travels.

And I have to ask ... how do you get to such poor health and not have plans for medical care while you're in another country (that you regularly visit) for an extended stay?
 
unionmom said:
And it still isn't the airlines' faults ... that is a major change in the needed accommodations to assist her in her travels.

And I have to ask ... how do you get to such poor health and not have plans for medical care while you're in another country (that you regularly visit) for an extended stay?

Vilma was already severely obese and in poor health from diabetes and kidney disease. She had lost a leg and used a wheelchair.


Chuck Bennett reports for the New York Post that the couple again went back to the vacation home to make other arrangements as Vilma became sicker and sicker. Neither trusted the doctors in Hungary, especially because they wouldn’t be familiar with her lengthy medical history, Janos said.

http://beforeitsnews.com/opinion-conservative/2012/11/morbidly-obese-woman-dies-after-3-airlines-refused-to-fly-her-2530936.html

I just don't see a court hearing this based on the fact she had a lengthy medical history of severe obesity and poor health from diabetes and kidney disease. She had lost a leg and used a wheelchair. :dunno
 
The more information I get on this story the more convinced I am that her hubby should have to pay legal fees for the airlines.

(And I love how he's only filing against two of the three airlines involved.)
 
LisaC said:
I don't know what to think about this one... She had to have an airlift to get on the plane. I appreciate her right to travel if she buys a seat, but seriously, if you have to have an airlift to get you ON the plane and you can't sit in a seat because it won't hold you, it really isn't the airline's fault (says the fat woman in the corner).

http://gma.yahoo.com/obese-woman-denied-flights-home-dies-abroad-191137549--abc-news-topstories.html

you keep taking my corner and you might see a law suit ...just sayin
 
Sadie612 said:
LisaC said:
I don't know what to think about this one... She had to have an airlift to get on the plane. I appreciate her right to travel if she buys a seat, but seriously, if you have to have an airlift to get you ON the plane and you can't sit in a seat because it won't hold you, it really isn't the airline's fault (says the fat woman in the corner).

http://gma.yahoo.com/obese-woman-denied-flights-home-dies-abroad-191137549--abc-news-topstories.html

you keep taking my corner and you might see a law suit ...just sayin

:spitchick
 
Back
Top